The Jeffrey G. Miller National Environmental Law Moot Court Competition (NELMCC)

Advancing Brief Writing and Oral Advocacy Skills
in Environmental Law

 

Outstanding Reputation.  NELMCC is the centerpiece of the Elisabeth Haub School of Law Environmental Law Program, ranked fourth in environmental law nationally by US News and World Report. Instituted in 1989, The Jeffrey G. Miller National Environmental Law Moot Court Competition (NELMCC) is the largest interschool moot court competition of any kind under one roof, regularly attracting 200 competitors from law schools from all over the nation. Highly competitive with tremendous educational value, NELMCC has established a national standard of excellence in moot court competitions.

Extraordinary Educational Experience. NELMCC provides an intellectual workout for competitors through complex legal analysis of today’s thorny environmental issues presented in the Problem. Competitors research and analyze the issues before writing persuasive arguments for one party advocating how the issues should be resolved. Competitors are then required to argue the issues orally for all three parties, rounding out the rigorous academic experience.

ABA SEER Award Winner. NELMCC is the recipient of the 2013 American Bar Association’s Section of Environment, Energy, and Resources Distinguished Achievement in Environmental Law and Policy Award for its broad national reach in engaging environmental law students on appellate brief writing and advocacy and commitment from environmental practitioners and the judiciary who judge and critique the competitors.

Great Location. The beautiful campus of Elisabeth Haub School of Law is located only 20 miles north of New York City with convenient access to the city and major airports.

Competition Office

Elisabeth Haub School of Law at Pace University
78 North Broadway, Preston 212
White Plains, NY 10603
914.422.4413
nelmcc@law.pace.edu

 

Rules and Problem

Rules

Click here for 2019 Official Rules

Problem

Revised Problem - October 26

Problem Questions and Answers Period ends October 29.

Question and Answers as of Oct. 30, 2018

 

2019 Team Briefs

Briefs: Service of Opposing Teams

In satisfaction of the requirement of service on opposing teams, the 2019 teams have submitted electronic briefs by email attachments. These files are in PDF format. Teams can be identified by their number.

Competitors: Please take a moment to look at your own team's brief and report any problems by email to nelmcc@law.pace.edu or telephone (914) 422-4426

LINKS TO INDIVIDUAL BRIEFS

Below are the links to the individual briefs. Although we have scanned all the files for viruses, saving the files gives your virus-scanning software a chance to rescan and is the best practice when downloading files from the web. If a team has withdrawn from the competition, their corresponding team number will not link to a brief.

Team 1 Team 30
Team 2 Team 31
Team 3 Team 32
Team 4 Team 33
Team 5 Team 34
Team 6 Team 35
Team 7 Team 36
Team 8 Team 37
Team 9 Team 38
Team 10 Team 39
Team 11 Team 40
Team 12 Team 41
Team 13 Team 42
Team 14 Team 43
Team 15 Team 44
Team 16 Team 45
Team 17 Team 46
Team 18 Team 47
Team 19 Team 48
Team 20 Team 49
Team 21 Team 50
Team 22 Team 51
Team 23 Team 52
Team 24 Team 53
Team 25 Team 54
Team 26 Team 55
Team 27 Team 56
Team 28  
Team 29  
   
   
   

 

Fact Sheet and Important Dates

Judging and CLE Information

If you would like to be a judge for NELMCC we have an online link to register. please contact lrubich@law.pace.edu for the link.

GENERAL INFORMATION ABOUT JUDGING
Preliminary rounds are scheduled for Thursday, February 21, 2019 from 9:30-11:30 am & 2:00-4:00 pm and Friday, February 22, from 9:30-11:30 am on the law school campus at 78 North Broadway in White Plains, New York. Interested attorneys are requested to register online.  Confirmation and judging materials will be sent to registered attorneys. Attorneys should arrive 30 minutes prior to their scheduled round for final instructions.

CLE CREDITS FOR JUDGING
Attorneys admitted to the New York bar for more than two years may earn two practice credits per round of judging. Attorneys in states other than New York will need to check with the state's CLE department to determine if the program will satisfy its requirements. Attorneys must sign in and out on the attendance sheet before and after each round of judging in order to receive CLE credits. According to New York State CLE rules, newly admitted attorneys (attorneys admitted to the bar less than two years from the competition date) cannot earn CLE credits for judging moot court competitions.

 

 

Oral Argument Judging Criteria

Click here for PDF of oral argument judging criteria

Click here for preliminary round judging form

Click here for quarter final and semi final round judging form

 

 

General Information

About the Competition

Every year law student advocates nationwide assemble at The Elisabeth Haub School of Law to compete in the largest interschool moot court competition under one roof. Over 200 competitors and 150 attorneys participate in grading briefs and serving as judges for the three day competition.

NELMCC tests students' skills in appellate brief writing and oral advocacy and uses issues drawn from real cases to provide students first-hand experience in environmental litigation while also providing a rigorous academic experience.

The Competition is distinctive in that three adverse teams argue the issues, reflecting the fact that environmental litigation frequently involves multiple parties — the government, a public interest group, and a member of the regulated industry.

Rounds

Oral arguments begin with preliminary rounds on Thursday and conclude with the final round on Saturday, which is open to the public. Judges evaluating the oral arguments include attorneys with environmental law expertise, local attorneys and judges from the nation’s courts. Final round judges are members of the federal and state benches and the US EPA’s Environmental Appeals Board.

The Problem

Each year the legal problem involves timely issues of national importance and/or internatonal importance to the practice of environmental law.

Hotel Information

Click here for Crowne Plaza booking information. The reservation deadline is January 28, 2019.

Transportation and Directions

Click here for ground transportation

Click here for directions to the law school

Give to NELMCC

Each year, our campaign goal is to raise money that will continue to grow NELMCC as a premier environmental moot court and add to the outstanding reputation of the Pace Environmental Law Program.
Please consider making a donation to NELMCC.   We rely 100% on the generous support of donors to help fund the administration of the event.
Based on your donation level, you will be recognized for your generosity in a variety of ways as shown on the enclosed sponsor form.  Click here for more information & donation levels 

CLICK HERE TO MAKE ONLINE DONATION
SPECIAL NOTE: CHECK THE BOX TO DESIGNATE YOUR GIFT TO THE  "NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL LAW MOOT COURT COMPETITION"

Thank you for supporting NELMCC.

 

Sponsors

The Jeffrey G. Miller National Environmental Law Moot Court Competition is grateful to the organizations and people whose generous financial support help make the event possible.

We are pleased to have the following as major supporters:

GHD ABA Section of Environment, Energy, and Resources
Environmental Law Institute Katten Muchin Rosenman

GHD
GHD is one of the world’s leading professional services companies operating in the global markets of water, energy and resources, environment, property and buildings, and transportation.
 
Privately owned by our people, GHD provides engineering, environmental and construction services to private and public sector clients across five continents and the Pacific region. Focused on creating lasting community benefit, our connected global network of 8500 people delivers projects with high standards of safety, quality and ethics.
 
Committed to sustainable development, GHD improves the physical, natural and social environments of the many communities in which we operate. www.ghd.com

American Bar Association
Section of Environment, Energy, and Resources

The mission of the American Bar Association (ABA) Section of Environment, Energy,and Resources is to be the premier forum for lawyers working in areas affecting the environment, energy, and resources. The Section is committed to providing member and public services to enhance professional skills, development, and dialogue on these subject areas.

It represents more than 11,000 members with a wide range of professional interests. The Section keeps its members abreast of development trends, current court decisions, legislative initiatives, and statutes concerning environmental, energy, and resource law.

The Section provides its members with up-to-date information through the quarterly magazine Natural Resources & Environment and the bimonthly newsletter, Trends. The Year in Review, an annual summary of judicial decisions, new legislation, and regulatory development, is written by members of the Section’s substantive committees and is provided to our lawyer members as a member benefit. Our book publishing program offers many nationally recognized titles such as Global Climate Change and U.S. Law, Environmental Justice: Theories and Procedures to Address Disproportionate Risk, Second Edition and Ocean and Coastal Law and Policy.

The Section’s substantive committees illustrate the breadth of issues addressed by the Section. Environmental, energy, resources and cross-practice committees disseminate topical information to our members through newsletters, Web sites, list serves and teleconference programs. Student members are welcome to join up to five committees for no additional fee. Committee membership allows you to connect with others who share your interests.

The ABA is the largest voluntary professional membership association in the world. With more than 410,000 members, the ABA provides law school accreditation, continuing legal education, information about the law, programs to assist lawyers and judges in their work, and initiatives to improve the legal system for the public.

For information about becoming a member of the ABA or its Section of Environment, Energy, and Resources, please call (800) 285-2221. For more information about the activities of the Section of Environment, Energy, and Resources, please visit http://www.abanet.org/environ/. Student resources are available at http://www.abanet.org/environ/committees/lawstudents/.

Environmental Law Institute

Environmental Moot ELI Sponsor 1Building on its history, reputation and experience, the Environmental Law Institute uses law and policy to create practical solutions to difficult environmental problems.  ELI combines penetrating analysis with the knowledge and energy of local partners to protect people, places, and the planet.  ELI gives citizens the information and skills they need to prosper while preserving the natural environment.

ELI’s books and periodicals, including the Environmental Law Reporter® and the National Wetlands Newsletter®, provide the environmental profession with cutting edge policy and legal analysis. The Institute invites students to join the ELI Associates Program for free to receive a subscription to the award winning The Environmental Forum®, the profession’s leading policy magazine, as well as a wealth of resources, such as ELI’s weekly e-mail bulletin, @eli.org, which updates members on recent developments and interesting career possibilities.

Team Registration and Payment

2019 Team Registration
Open Through September 28, 2018

Online Registration and Payment Form

General Information – Registration is limited to one team per school. Each team must complete the online registration form. The nonrefundable registration fee is $550.00 payable online by credit card or check. Checks should be made payable to Elisabeth Haub School of Law-NELMCC and mailed to our office with school name and a copy of the registration confirmation email. The registration fee covers light breakfasts, lunches and receptions during the competition for the team. Teams are responsible for travel, accommodations and other expenses.

Registration Acceptance & Deadline – The registration deadline is September 28, 2018. Late Registrations will be considered if space allows.
The office will notify the team contact when the school is officially registered.

The Problem will be distributed by email on or about October 8, 2018 to the Team Contact of all registered teams.

 

Team Coach Information

Please complete the requested information by December 7. The school’s team number was provided earlier to the team contact or you may email the NELMCC office at nelmcc@law.pace.edu.

Click here for the form

Team Confirmation Form

The Team Member Confirmation Form should be completed and submitted as soon as the team is constituted AFTER the release of the Problem but no later than October 26.  Please refer to Rule III (B) of the Official Rules.

Your team number, which is required to complete the form, is provided in the Problem & Rules distribution email to the team contact from each school on October 8, 2018. Please refer to the original email or, if needed, contact the NELMCC office.

Click here for the form.

 

History of "Dawn-Storm King" Painting

Click here for the background and history of the original "Dawn-Storm King" watercolor painting. The painting is exhibited each year by the winning school of the competition.  

Previous Competitions

Here is link to our NELMCC guide 2011-present:  Jeffrey G. Miller National Environmental Law Moot Court Competition (NELMCC)

 

2018 Competition